In 1984, Wendy’s (a fast food restaurant in the United States) came up with an advertisement that coined the phrase "Where’s the Beef?". The announcement today of the much awaited ‘deal’ to save the bond insurer Ambac (ABK) made everyone say "Where’s the Beef?"
At 12:01pm today trading was halted on Ambac with news pending. With this news, speculation that a bail out plan was finalized and the idea that the entire bond insurer mess would now be ending, the markets went higher in just seconds. It took almost 90 minutes before the market knew the details of the ‘bail out’ plan that had been worked on for many weeks. When the details were released it was a huge disappointment and the markets quickly sold down, losing 120 points on the Dow within 10 minutes.
So what was it that was so disappointing? In order to put this in the proper perspective, we have to rewind the clock a bit. First of all, the bond insurer crisis began many months ago. It accelerated around the beginning of this year as the ratings agencies were threatening to downgrade Ambac and MBIA which, if it happened, would create substantial additional losses throughout the financial sector. Both MBIA and Ambac were under pressure to find additional capital, maintaining enough liquidity to meet the requirements that the ratings agencies claimed was needed to have a AAA rating. Last month news was issued by CNBC reporter, Charlie Gasparino, that Ambac was working on a "plan" to rescue the company. This involved government officials (NY Governer Elliot Spitzer and NY Insurance Superintendent Mr. Dinallo), sovereign wealth funds, and banks. Over the next 4 weeks or so we would receive updates from the media, mostly Charlie Gasparino of CNBC, that the rescue plan was being worked on…
2/18: Ambac Financial Group, Inc Ambac discussing plan to raise at least $2B in new capital; Plans to sell new shares at a discount to current investors as reported in the WSJ
2/22: Ambac Financial Group, Inc Making significant progress on recapitilization, announcement on possible bailout could come early next week as per CNBCs Charlie Gasparino
2/24: Ambac Financial Group, Inc WSJ says that Ambac inched closer over the weekend to an agreement with a group of bankers on its restructuring plan and effort to raise $3B
2/25: Ambac Financial Group, Inc Deal still likely today or tomorrow; negotiations with rating agencies are final hurdle as per CNBCs Charlie Gasparino.
2/25: (later in the day) Ambac Financial Group, Inc Any ABK deal would likely be early next week, not today or tomorrow - wire headline.
2/26: Ambac Financial Group, Inc - reports that private equity and unexposed banks will be participating in Ambac support plan as per CNBCs Charlie Gasparino.
2/27: Ambac Financial Group, Inc NY Insurance Superintendent Dinallo: We are in the 8th inning of a possible Ambac rescue - wires
2/27: Ambac Financial Group, Inc Cerberus among group of investors in bailout, declines to comment - CNBC’s Liesman
2/29: Ambac Financial Group, Inc Bailout has hit significant snag over last couple days over the amount of capital, talks ongoing as per CNBCs Charlie Gasparino
3/3: Ambac Financial Group, Inc CNBC’s Gasparino incremental update: Negotiations with a bank consortium are going slowly, no deal announcement expected tomorrow
3/3: Ambac Financial Group, Inc - Financial Times reports that Ambac has decided against splitting
- The company decided against splitting in two as it completes a $2-3B recapitalization
3/4: Ambac Financial Group, Inc - says no bailout deal quite yet as per CNBCs Charlie Gasparino
- Reiterates that progress is still being made
3/4: Ambac Financial Group, Inc - Says those working on the deal "may work through the night" to close a deal for some kind of announcement tomorrow as per CNBCs Charlie Gasparino
3/5: Ambac Financial Group, Inc CNBC’s Gasparino reiterates that banks seeking to have rescue package to be finalized today
And then came the "deal" that had been worked on for so long…
NEW YORK (Reuters) - Bond insurer Ambac Financial Group Inc (NYSE:ABK) said on Wednesday it plans to sell at least $1.5 billion of stock and convertible securities, to help preserve the top-tier credit ratings critical for its main insurance business.
That’s it! No consortium of banks, no sovereign wealth funds, nothing. Weeks of back room negotiations ended up being nothing more than a dilution of the company’s stock by selling $1.0 Billion of stock and another $500 million through the sale of equity units that would convert to stock in May 2011.
So what happened to all that talk of big bail outs, of banks injecting substantial amounts of money, and to the original plan to raise $3 Billion dollars?
Reuters reported the following comment tonight:
"It looks like (banks) had a close look at what was going on at Ambac, and they backed away. Things may be bad there," said Peter Kovalski, portfolio manager at Alpine Woods Capital Investors, which owns Ambac shares.
Shortly after the news was released by Ambac, Moody’s and Standard & Poor’s issued statements that Ambac would likely maintain their AAA rating. But Fitch ratings said no way, leaving Ambac at AA.
So this entire soap opera had many in the media, especially Charlie Gasparino at CNBC, being played along the entire time. And every time there was another new update about the rescue plan (always from someone known only as "someone familiar with the situation"), it created a lift to the markets and to Ambac stock. Something about this entire situation does not sit right with me, there is something that does not smell pretty at Ambac!
Ambac’s stock sold off rapidly after this news and ended the day down 18.8%, and down another 3.4% in after hours trading. This bond insurer situation has to be one of the largest debacles in recent history. Where will this all end up? It depends on how many claims Ambac has to pay over time as the credit implosion continues to play out. We could be right back where we started in weeks or months down the road, if Ambac needs even more capital to maintain enough liquidity. The ratings agencies are still, in my view, disgustingly guilty of not being impartial.
Stay tuned for the next episode of the soap opera "As the Bond Insurers Fail"
Then there is this tonight:
According to Bloomberg, almost 70% of the municipal auctions in the $330 billion auction-rate market failed last week. (Auction-rate securities represent about 13% of the total market for municipal debt.) Failed auctions create a vicious cycle: As municipalities are hit with penalty rates on their debt, it erodes their capital position, increasing the risk of a bond default. This further depresses demand for municipal securities, causing even more auctions to fail.
The market remains VERY jittery and the biggest economic data is still to come. The monthly unemployment report will be issued at 8:30am on Friday. We got a small taste of what it may show as the ADP report today showed a negative number for the first time in 4 years. ADP has usually been all over the map with regard to their accuracy, but the number was substantially lower than even the lowest of estimates. The market is still pricing in a significant rate cut from the Federal Reserve. We remain short the Dow Jones Industrials.





1 Comments
March 6th, 2008 at 7:47 am
LOL… “Where’s the BEEF!” — Including the stock market! Beware - major stock PE contraction is next….