Just two weeks ago General Motors (GM) announced that they had reimbursed the government (taxpayers) by paying back the balance of the TARP $6.7 Billion loan. General Motors even went on the air with the following television commercial:
But is General Motors being completely honest? Not according to Senator Charles Grassley, Republican of Iowa and Neil Barofsky, inspector general for the TARP. Essentially all that General Motors did was to use ‘other’ taxpayer funds held by the Treasury to pay off its original loan. This makes the claims that General Motors has repaid their debt to the American tax payers a tricky shell game.
In a letter sent to Secretary Tim Geithner on April 22, 2010 Senator Grassley had this to say:
Dear Secretary Geithner:
General Motors (GM) yesterday announced that it repaid its TARP loans. I am
concerned, however, that this announcement is not what it seems. In fact, it appears to be nothing more than an elaborate TARP money shuffle.On Tuesday of this week, Mr. Neil Barofsky, the Special Inspector General for
TARP, testified before the Senate Finance Committee. During his testimony Mr.
Barofsky addressed GM’s recent debt repayment activity, and stated that the funds GM is using to repay its TARP debt are not coming from GM earnings. Instead, GM seems to be using TARP funds from an escrow account at Treasury to make the debt repayments.The most recent quarterly report from the Office of the Special Inspector General for TARP says “The source of funds for these quarterly [debt] payments will be other TARP funds currently held in an escrow account.” See, Office of the Special Inspector General for TARP, Quarterly Report to Congress dated April 20, 2010, page 115.
Furthermore, Exhibit 99.1 of the Form 8K filed by GM with the SEC on
November 16, 2009, seems to confirm that the source of funds for GM’s debt repayments was a multi-billion dollar escrow account at Treasury—not from earnings […][…] Therefore, it is unclear how GM and the Administration could have accurately announced yesterday that GM repaid its TARP loans in any meaningful way. In reality, it looks like GM merely used one source of TARP funds to repay another. The taxpayers are still on the hook, and whether TARP funds are ultimately recovered depends entirely on the government’s ability to sell GM stock in the future. Treasury has merely exchanged a legal right to repayment for an uncertain hope of sharing in the future growth of GM. A debt-for-equity swap is not a repayment.[…] (Senate documents)
Furthermore, the Congressional Budget Office maintains their estimates that the American taxpayers in the end will lose approximately $30 Billion of the total General Motors bailout funds.
So did General Motors pay back the taxpayers? No, they just moved funds from one account
to another. General Motors, and the U.S. Treasury Department, have simply pulled a fast one on the American taxpayer with what appears to be nothing more than an old fashioned shell game.




